Discuss R232 SL AMG vs. The Competition


GTA45E

Premium+
Premium
Which one of these convertibles would you choose based on features, packaging, and overall appearance.
Also, give opinions on how the new SL55, 63 is going to stack up against the competition on appearance and features.

SL AMG
ofmonAI.webp


BMW M8
DjiCo6s.webp


Lexus LC500
Nh5hTJu.webp


Aston Martin DB11 volante
oGUo7PH.webp


Porsche 911 Cabrio
Ag5GUaP.webp


Ferrari Portofino
ZYCi5lx.webp
 
If I had the funds...

1) Porsche - 911 does almost everything right, it's an icon, with a frunk and rear seats there's solid amounts of cargo. In base or S form, still plenty of power though I suspect ride might be too firm for lazy Sunday morning type cruising, and now that I am at that age where my back is getting progressively worse, that now something I'd consider.

2) SL - iconic though it's status has faded in the last decade. Plenty of oomph and I suspect a more compliant ride. Prestige but not terribly obnoxious about it; an inline-6 in this appeals to me.

3) LC500 - just love this thing. Looks out of this world and I suspect with its tried and true NA V8, this thing will run forever if properly maintained. Love the interior but the human interface sucks. It'll be rare and it'll remain a treat.

4) tied - Portofino. Fantastic except for the nosebleed price.

4) tied - Conti GT V8 Cab. Though not included in the above list of contenders, thought I include it since the Portofino was included. The interior is so expensive-looking and precious, you want to make sure you take a shower every time right before you get in and drive as to not mess it up in any way. Looks like a proper cruiser and I suspect the ride can be adjusted to where the ride quality has a wide range of adjustability.

6) 840i - solid exterior design if a bit generic, solid interior if a bit standard BMW fare, solid features, crap resale. I'd stick with the I-6 engine for the smoothness, and like the SL, the great cruising potential. IMO, the 8er makes a more compelling case in GC guise than in 2-door form.

7) DB11 - I just don't find the exterior captivating, especially as I've considered its predecessor, the DB9 and Virage, to be proportionally perfect.
 
Toss up between the SL and 911 simply because I've always wanted a SL, not because this new SL is a more appealing car. Then it would be the BMW, Ferrari, Lexus and the Aston last. The DB11 is emphatically NOT the DBS.

M
 
1. SL over any cab 911 unless GTS then I need a long time to think.. but Ile say SL/911 first.

2. LC 500 it’s baller

3. portofino , somewhat a woman’s car but it’s nice

4. Aston and bmw hate both.
 
1.) 992 Carrera cabriolet

2.) Lexus LC500

3.) Ferrari Portofino

4.) R232 SL

5.) DB11 Volante (now, a DBS Superleggera Volante would have been runner-up to the 992)

6.) G14 8er
 

Thread statistics

Created
GTA45E,
Last reply from
Deleted member 57437,
Replies
7
Views
989

Trending content


Back
Top