Reviews I had the BMW i8 for 72 hours.


Centurion

Apex Apex Predator
Hello everyone
BMW UK lent me an i8 for 72 hours. Hungry for delicious fish and chips I drove it down to cliffs of Beachy Head and Hastings on the southern coast of England, where I enjoyed fresh air and twisty roads. Here's my BMW i8 review.

3c1500a95e831d69b0d4fe2aefe8de25._.webp

6ec1eb306f584ae69f2f6b679c86e9c8._.webp


What is it?
A hybrid GT(Yes a GT, not supercar) with a 228hp 3 cylinder petrol engine at the rear and a 129hp electric motor at the front. They develop a combined 570nm at 320nm and 250nm respectively.


How does it drive?
Have you ever played a video game with fictional cars that have perfect physics? Well, the i8 drives like one of them. It’s fast, has no body roll and grips like it’s on rails.

The star of the show is without a doubt the drivetrain. Whether you are driving relaxed in bumper to bumper traffic or breezing through country roads, the drivetrain never misunderstands your intentions. It knows when to only engage the electric motor and when to keep the turbo spooled and ready to punch. BMW have absolutely nailed the software that governs the interplay between gearbox, petrol engine and electric motor.

Only when flooring it from standstill do you notice a split second step at around 40mph when the electric motor starts to run out of breath and the petrol engine catches up. Except for that, the drivetrain is so step-less to the point that unless you have read the specs, you wouldn’t be able to guess what’s powering the car.

It’s an amazing drivetrain!

3b6d79f4774bcf6620cb1308b44bc727._.webp

22f436b97a096bf6a76a966a2860c694._.webp

efc5f6784a562233e358a9a3028924fa._.webp

The bad bits
  • Looks can be deceiving. Despite the supercar design, the i8 drives like a GT. The steering has a small dead zone and is not sharp nor communicative enough for you to feel “one with the car”.
  • Although fun, the fake engine note can feel unnecessary in sport mode as it’s not as erotic as satin underwear or the thunder and crackling of a Maserati GranTurismo.
  • Because of the obtrusive monocoque, getting in and out of the car is a clumsy task. Facing away from the car you slide the bum into the seat, close your legs together and swing them 90 degrees into the car. If the car is wet, your calves will touch the side skirt and get soiled. I kept my white Dockers in the wardrobe for this one.

The good bits.
  • Grand tourers are typically heavy and clumsy, but the i8 isn’t. Leave it in auto and the low centre of gravity and smooth drive train offer a comfortable and effortless cruise. Performance is easily accessible and traction is difficult to break. Best of all, it is nimble and feels small around town and in parking lots.

Does it attract a lot of attention?
The exterior has the appearance of a movie prop from a Tom Cruise Scifi and attracts curiosity. A typical comment is “It’s electric right?, as if the public is unsure about whether it’s a car of the future of not. Thankfully, the i8 is available without silly blue accents all over the exterior. It’s a head turner but not a showstopper or attention magnet like a Lamborghini. Inside, all sort of beeps and boings can be heard when on ignition. It’s akin to preparing for take off in a spaceship.

1c289219e308544e65cc42a2bebf5b9b._.webp

3ad06367a0df0029a006a723e7438679._.webp

5b63890a455b0f56085fcb56524eccf5._.webp

44a9332635b7832ba953fed3198af47f._.webp

a61de1e3f0e0cec8af20df3f0e8ad77f._.webp



Is it better than the Tesla Model S?
In electric drive, the i8 has a range of 25 miles and loses breath at 40mph while the Tesla has a range up to 380 miles and can do 0-62mph in 2.8sec. While the i8 is a taster of the future, the Tesla is the future, has 4 seats and is available to buy not in year 2020 or 2030 but today in 2017.


Who is it for?
At £109,000/$140,700/€130.000,00 the i8 is a very expensive car. The the AMG GT, 911 GTS, M6, R8 V10, Model S and S Class coupe cost as much but are more practical GTs or offer the drama and exhilaration expected of a supercar. While the i8 has many qualities to appreciate, it’s a master of none.

Put that drive train in a 4-Series and there’ll be plenty of people who will be happy to leave the famous BMW straight 6 in the past. The i8 is not the electric BMW the world has been waiting for.
 
Very informative. Until now I hadn't realised white dockers were still a thing ;)

Seriously though, cool pics... but no lemon with the fish at a sit down chippy would have pissed me off.
 
So a few questions...

How useful did you find the rear seats, especially since you (and I) would consider this more of a GT than an all-out sportscar?

Is the ingress and egress to the rear seats markedly worse than the front or the same?

Would it be practical as a daily driver or would the many quirks become more annoying than charming with time, i.e. swing-up doors?

Considering that a BMW dealer let you have a go at this for 72 hours, what is their assessment for how well this is doing in the UK market? Have the dealer folks mentioned what their wishlist for a next-gen i8 would be?
 
Considering that a BMW dealer let you have a go at this for 72 hours, what is their assessment for how well this is doing in the UK market?

Well, as you hint at, dealers don't give 72 hour test drives for cars that are flying out of the showrooms. BMW Finance are also offering over £15,000 towards the deposit on new i8s. It's clearly not selling.

Like I've said many times before, people may admire the i8 and talk about it in favourable terms. But when it comes to putting their hands in their pockets they're nowhere to be seen. The car has a six figure price tag which is absolutely insane.
 
Very informative. Until now I hadn't realised white dockers were still a thing ;)

Seriously though, cool pics... but no lemon with the fish at a sit down chippy would have pissed me off.

Thanks! My white dockers are for dressy alfresco lunches in the summer.

Yup, I was slacking on the lemon. I love lemon, but in my defence the their daily caught cod is so brilliant white, flaky and delicious that you forget about must-have condiments!

So a few questions...

How useful did you find the rear seats, especially since you (and I) would consider this more of a GT than an all-out sportscar?

Is the ingress and egress to the rear seats markedly worse than the front or the same?

Would it be practical as a daily driver or would the many quirks become more annoying than charming with time, i.e. swing-up doors?

Considering that a BMW dealer let you have a go at this for 72 hours, what is their assessment for how well this is doing in the UK market? Have the dealer folks mentioned what their wishlist for a next-gen i8 would be?

BMW UK head office lent me the car which is owned by them and not linked to a franchised dealer.

I’m glad you asked about the rear seats! I took my partner and our then 5 month old baby for a drive in the i8. She sat behind me while the baby was rearward facing behind the passenger seat. Let just saw neither of us were 100% comfortable!

3c5af04912aac2c37d48dffcd7c0e7f5._.webp


Because the front seats are electric it takes ages to slide and tip them to access the rear seats which, like with many 2+2s, are just for emergency or storage. In the case of the i8, the boot only has room for a briefcase or a bag of groceries.

Owners are likely to lease the i8 through their business because of tax breaks for low emission cars, and own a second car better suited to everyday practicality. Surprisingly it’s well damped on rough roads and delightfully fluid to drive, but is only suitable as a daily driver to bachelors.

If I remember correctly, well under 2,000 i8s are produced annually which is a strong reflection of how niche the car is.

Well, as you hint at, dealers don't give 72 hour test drives for cars that are flying out of the showrooms. BMW Finance are also offering over £15,000 towards the deposit on new i8s. It's clearly not selling.

Like I've said many times before, people may admire the i8 and talk about it in favourable terms. But when it comes to putting their hands in their pockets they're nowhere to be seen. The car has a six figure price tag which is absolutely insane.

If BMW sharpened the steering and made the tyres feedback a bit, it would have been a purposeful supercar rather a car with a confused identity.

Damn forget about the car those fish and chips looks amazing, you just can't get fish and chips in Norway that a person could realistically eat!

For the freshest and tastiest fish and chips, Hastings it the place to go! I don’t bother buying it anywhere else. I wish I had taken a photo of fish cod filet under the batter.

Freaking epic. Looks absolutely amazing, and even a bit scary.

Maybe time for a fence :p

Beachy Head is stunning place but when you are there you can’t see down over edge and are oblivious to the 162m drop down.

Here's a photo not taken by me.
8325a30da26784641a5490154573828a.webp
 
^eep, as clutzy as I am, I wouldn't trust myself on that path especially with the fog rolling in like that.

Regarding the i8, I am intrigued by it but I don't know if I'd choose this over, say, 911. If already had a 911, I might consider it more seriously as left-field alternative.

Thanks for the write-up and response.
 
^eep, as clutzy as I am, I wouldn't trust myself on that path especially with the fog rolling in like that.

And it looks like the cliff is slowly eating into the country, or possibly rapidly due to rising seas.
Looks like the road can erode away at any moment....
 
And it looks like the cliff is slowly eating into the country, or possibly rapidly due to rising seas.
Looks like the road can erode away at any moment....
I believe the sedimentary soil there is limestone and weathering is primarily due to wind and moisture content of the air. Rapidly rising sea does not play a critical factor here, but the fact that cliff is facing the sea means that the moisture content of the air around the cliff is certainly higher than it is as one goes further inland.
 
I believe the sedimentary soil there is limestone and weathering is primarily due to wind and moisture content of the air. Rapidly rising sea does not play a critical factor here, but the fact that cliff is facing the sea means that the moisture content of the air around the cliff is certainly higher than it is as one goes further inland.

Agreed, but the waves will surely effect it too, when it eats away the cliff on sea level there will be an effect on the top eventually.
 
Great review and thanks for the fantastic pics. The scenery is gorgeous and the fish and chips looks yummy!
 

Thread statistics

Created
Centurion,
Last reply from
Betty Swollocks,
Replies
21
Views
1,121

Trending content


Back
Top