4T : Reviews & Road Tests
Anticipation is a common theme when it comes to the Audi S3 sedan. This is the first time Audi has ventured into the A3 range with in its S-Car lineup for America. That the car means a potent offering in a package roughly equivalent to the much beloved B5 Audi S4 sedan only compounds the level of expectation levied upon this new offering. Given all this, we were eager to get our hands on the S3 and see first hand just how good it really is. A visit to Texas for the American round of the 2014 World Endurance Championship afforded us our first real opportunity.
S3 Background
The Audi S3 launching in America is actually the third-generation of the model. The first (type 8L), sold as a 3-door only and arrived during the same era as the aforementioned B5 S4. That first car was effectively on the same platform as the first-generation Audi TT. In fact, it shared the TT’s most potent 225 hp 1.8T engine and 6-speed transmission, as well as its Haldex-based quattro all-wheel drive system.
Audi stuck to formula when it introduced the second-generation S3 (type 8P). A three door only affair in the beginning, the car spawned a Sportback mid-lifecycle when that body style became available. Nevertheless, the car used effectively the same 261 bhp 2.0 TFSI engine and drivetrain as the second-generation TTS.
With the latest S3 family based on Audi’s MQB architecture (type 8V), the model lineup has expanded beyond the usual 3-door and 5-door Sportback models to also include the Cabriolet and sedan. The Cabriolet is a Europe only affair, though the sedan is very much geared mainly toward markets like America and also China.
Capturing the Spirit of the B5 S4
In many ways, the B5 Audi S4 represents that ex girlfriend or boyfriend you’ve always wondered about getting back together. By going to the larger B6 and B7 platforms with their aftermarket unfriendly normally aspirated V8 engine or larger-yet B8 S4, fans of that original B5 S4 were simply left yearning for another go. Those elder S4s still command a premium in the aftermarket due to their high degree of tune-ability and also for their small and agile size… a premium and refined product in a package more akin to a Subaru WRX STi or Mitsubishi Lancer EVO.
With the new S3 sedan, Audi aims to recapture that old magic. In regards to packaging, they’re awfully close. The S3 measures up, 1.8 inches wider, 1.3 inches shorter front-to-rear and .8 inches taller in height as compared to the B5. The new car’s wheelbase is .8 inches longer, with shorter front and rear overhangs and wider track as a result of that wider footprint. In size, the only measurement where the S3 is less aggressive than the B5 S4 is height, and we’re wondering how much of that might be due to what seems to be a relatively tall factory ride height.
Under the hood, the new S3 also compares quite favorably. Where as the B5 S4’s 2.7-liter biturbo V6 pushed out 250 hp at 5800 rpm and 258 lb-ft at 1850 rpm, the S3’s 2.0 TFSI inline 4-cylinder delivers more – 292 hp at 5400 rpm and 280 lb-ft at 1900 rpm. Given the S3 weighs about 400 lbs. less (3200 lbs. versus the old S4’s 3593 lbs.), it should be no surprise that it scorches the B5 S4’s fuel economy (23 city/31 highway vs. 16 city/22 highway) and also beats up on the earlier car’s 0-60 mph numbers ( 4.7 seconds versus 5.4 seconds).
While one might cast romantic favor to the long gone B5 S4, the new Audi S3 sedan beats it by essentially every measure as defined by data.
Okay, Audi traditionalists and purists may grouse that the S3 isn’t a “Torsen quattro”. To the uninitiated, that means a mechanical differential supplying power to the front and rear, which is essentially standard fare on Audis with longitudinal (north-south) engines. Everything from the original ur quattro to today’s S4 and above have a longitudinally mounted engine with mechanical center differential, so there’s a certain pedigree people yearn for.
Call me untraditional though, because I’m not willing to write off the S3’s transversely mounted (east-west) engine and the computer controlled Haldex center differential. Yes, earlier Haldex cars like every S3 and TT before the current versions did effectively run front-wheel drive unless called upon to act, and yes that may have been viewed as
not superior to the all-time all-wheel drive of the so-called “Torsen” cars, but hold on a second.
One big advantage for transverse Audis has always been an engine mounted lower and more to the center of the chassis. This helps handling. More importantly, the latest Haldex 5 powered version of quattro pairs the system-controlling software with the Audi Drive Select system, meaning it can be proactive in its torque delivery rather than purely reactive like the mechanical systems. Turn the system to a performance setting and this only gets more pronounced. Here too, the S3 sedan appears to be superior to that original S4.
Impressions of the S3
As for how pretty the current is compared to the ex, looks are in the eyes of the beholder. The B5-generation Audi has always been a favorite to fans of the brand – a modern style icon with excellent proportions. In comparison, the shape of the production S3 is a bit tall. The low suspension and lower roof of the first A3 sedan concept car that previewed this latest sedan was more cartoonish and closer to the first car in spirit. The new S3 seems visually taller, though wrapped in some seriously handsome bodywork, with taller shoulders and tornado line doing their best to mask the fact that Audi wanted more headroom for all four passengers this time around.
Fitted with optional LED headlights, the look of the S3 is captivating. Silver brightwork on the grille’s horizontal struts also carries over to more traditional placement like the rearview mirrors and lower valances. Our car came on 19-inch 5-star double spoke wheels, an option that seems like a bit of a must in order to separate your S3 from more run-of-the-mill A3 sedans. It all makes for a look that is equal parts familiar, modern and also menacing.
Inside, the S3’s interior is impressive. The car’s sport seats are handsome and willing to grip, and those seating surfaces will be even better when the late-intro diamond-stitched super sport seats finally arrive in a few months’ time.
There’s just one beltline trim for now, and that’s the same aluminum as seen in the more common A3. That’s a shame. The first B5 S4 had a wood option, and while that may be less popular nowadays, every S4 since has offered carbon fiber. For the S3, there is no such option… at least not yet.
From an infotainment perspective, it’s no surprise that the S3 beats the hell out of that old S4. Those were the days before modern navigation or Bluetooth systems. While owners of B5 S4s sift through internet forums and German Ebay searching for ways to retrofit a later and nowadays archaic Audi RNSE navigation system, the S3 sedan boasts a motorized screen as thin as an iPhone that’ll deliver up Google maps and search functionality animated seamlessly thanks to an NVIDIA Tegra 2 graphics chip. There’s 4G wi-fi, which also powers built-in MMI functionality like Facebook and Twitter, while you listen to satellite radio and tag songs so you can download them now and listen to them later.
Yes, there’s an app for all that. It’s called “MMI connect” though we’ve not had a chance to fully test it. More on that from us at a later date.
Fire up the S3 and the 2.0 TFSI has a more aggressive soundtrack than the identically named but lower powered 2.0 TFSI in the Audi A3. Part of that is because there’s a sound-augmenting speaker that transfers engine tone into the cabin. Part of that is also due to the more aggressive exhaust that blat/burps on shifts much as you’d expect from the angry little sibling of the Audi RS 7.
For now, there’s just one transmission – a 6-speed S tronic dual clutch sequential also known as DSG. It is fast, it is intuitive, it is more aggressively programmed than the same unit in the Audi A3 sedan. That’s all a great thing, but here’s where purists will grouse. Always logical Audi engineers will argue to you that a DSG is both more efficient and faster… and they’re right. Even still, I’ll side with the purists on the right to choose.
Unless I lived in a city with constant bumper-to-bumper traffic, I’d want the manual. There’s something more self gratifying, more engaging and even magical about rowing your own gears, rev matching and pairing it all with an empty snaking back road. Yes, the S tronic is very good and yes the steering wheel paddles on the flat-bottom wheel are satisfying to use as well, but not as much as the manual is for those who see shifting as an art.
Germany gets the manual, and frankly we should too. Good news on that front.
Audi of America President Scott Keogh spoke of the S3 manual at the recent Audi Club national event in Texas, and the head of Audi’s US presence made it sound as if the decision may have already been made to add the gearbox as an option in the future. We’re keeping our fingers crossed.
So how does the car drive? We sampled the S3 over several hours in a mix of both long highways and some winding roads outside of Austin, TX. Later, we hit the Circuit of the Americas for one quick but unfortunately lone lap of the Circuit of the Americas.
On the road, the S3 is comfortable. It’ll go all Clark Kent for the daily slog, with plenty of torque on hand, sipping fuel conservatively and lulling you to a state of satisfaction as it delivers your favorite playlist, audio book or whatever over the optional and highly impressive Bang & Olufsen audio system.
In the twisties, or better yet on the track chasing one Allan McNish in an Audi R8 V10 plus, it wears the S on its grille as proudly as Superman would on his chest. Power is good, steering is well-weighted and direct. In this iteration, the latest Haldex version of quattro is quick to move power to the rear, allowing for some subtle throttle-on oversteer when you finally do push it past its highly impressive level of adhesion.
Conclusion
So, does it measure up? Is it better than the B5 S4?
We’d say yes on most every level. Out of the box, it is a much better package than was the B5 S4. Its base price of $41,100 is a lot closer to the original price of the B5 S4 than is the adjustment for inflation. That said, you can quickly option this thing over and above the $50,000 mark if you like options… and we like options.
Will it prove as tune-able as the B5 S4? That’s hard to say. The old S4’s V6 offered more displacement, so those willing to throw caution to the wind for a big turbo upgrade could and did mess with supercars. This one will beat up on a WRX STi in stock form, and companies like APR say the unpublished numbers they are getting from initial tunes of the S3’s engine are nothing short of awesome. Whether they’re super car beater awesome remains to be seen, but we’ve no doubt they will make the S3 a rabid wolf in snarling German Shephard clothing.
In the end, we leave the S3 very satisfied. Things like performance, efficiency, infotainment, even creature comforts set it far ahead of the B5 S4 and also many of its rivals. Shortcomings are few, but still there. We wish it had a manual option, and the interior with its super clean dashboard design and lack of trim options is a bit too streamlined for our taste… though nothing a little carbon fiber and some diamond stitch sport seats wouldn’t fix. Likely that’s all coming any way, which makes us confidently say that while we have a soft spot in our hearts for the old ex, this latest relationship has every indication that it’s a keeper.
http://fourtitude.com/features/Reviews_amp_Road_Tests_14/driven-2015-audi-s3-sedan/