Comparison tests Motorsport Magazine Lamborghini Performante vs Porsche 911GT2RS vs McLaren 720S


Laurent T

Premium
Finally one of the tests I've been waiting for is here. Did not expect the Lambo to join the two others, but it was here. I won't post all pages because I have no scanner and just the paper edition (Zinio does not sell the mag anymore). I will sum up once I have read everything in details.
Tires played again I think a big part in the results with two important things to note :
- Porsche 911 was like for AMS test with Cup 2 standard, not R.
- Seems that the McLaren has been fitted for first with Trofeo R - may explain part of the great performance and put it with same tires than the Lambo.
Winner McLaren with 20/20 (19/20 for the 2 others). Best also on road, circuit & performances. Only lost to the Lambo for engine.
More to come during the week-end...
 

Attachments

  • 20180616_103317.webp
Do the Trofeo2 tires make a huge difference compared to say the Michelin Cup2? I only found two test of both tires compared to the Dunlop SportMaxx, Toyo Proxes and Yokohama Advan. The testcar was a Golf R 7.5 and the outgoing Focus ST. The PZero Trofeo won on the Golf R and the Michelin Cup2 on the ST. Is there a considerably difference between these two semi-slicks?
 
Do the Trofeo2 tires make a huge difference compared to say the Michelin Cup2? I only found two test of both tires compared to the Dunlop SportMaxx, Toyo Proxes and Yokohama Advan. The testcar was a Golf R 7.5 and the outgoing Focus ST. The PZero Trofeo won on the Golf R and the Michelin Cup2 on the ST. Is there a considerably difference between the two semi-slicks?
Don't know about this... but the big difference for the McLaren is that it has been tested to date only on Corsa and never on Trofeos. So Trofeos for this test must have helped the lap times and to do better than th two other tested "track weapons".
 
That blue on the Performante, wow what a stunning machine. Does anyone know the paint for it?

Incredible to see that there is only .05 between the top two considering the difference in HP and Price.

Porsche seemed to be out of luck without it`s Cup 2Rs.
 
18,2 s @ 298 kph (0-300 kph in ca. 18,5 s) - Motorsport :eek:
18,1 s @ 294 kph (0-300 kph in 19,4 s) - AutoBild Sportscars
 
All three cars have been tested on two circuits. Porsche & McLaren on same day, Lamborghini for the previous issue.
Let's speak about tires from the beginning : Porsche on standard Cup 2, Lamborghini on Trofeo R. The McLaren did its first laps on Magny Cours GP (longest of the two test tracks) with the standard P Zero Corsa before switching to the same Trofeo R than the Lamborghini.
Car tested on Track for chassis but ESP intermediate did 1'48"7 with Corsa & 1'48"21 with Trofeo. Best lap has been achieved on a further run with ESP off... in 1'47"05. That's quite a gap. Pilot comments :
- GT2RS : good grip, excellent balance, excellent motricity and chassis able to handle 50 to 100 more PS.
- McLaren : most sensational engine he ever tested. More stable (in particular on braking) than 675LT & 570S. Understeer during acceleration + torque management not has good as Porsche = more touchy at the limit than the Porsche.
- Lambo : favorite car from the test pilot.
McLaren impressive on track due to its more "polyvalent" orientation : it's not a track weapon with specific wing and high load aerodynamics. Addictive, in-cre-di-ble !
On the Club track (shortest of the two). Here as well, the GT2 RS is relatively easy to manage and not the widow maker of the past. Overall, all three are a tremendous experience and do not get any specific negative comment.
Weight measured on test cars (full fluids, no driver) : 911 GT2 RS = 1515kg (Pack Weissach) ; 720S = 1454kg ; Performante = 1526kg.
Engine/Transmission : 1.Performante 2.720S 3.GT2 RS ; a little more turbo lag on the McLaren but impressive thrust. Best engine is the naturally aspirated V10 though.
Performances : 1.720S 2. GT2 RS 3. Performante ; you have the data, nothing more to say.
Road : 1.720S 2.Performante 3.GT2 RS ; Magnetic Ride works well on the Lamborghini and helps to exploit it on the road. Suspensions very stiff for the Porsche. McLaren in its element with great suspensions, most confortable, wonderful steering, motricity very close to the GT2 RS. Best tool currently available.
Circuit : 1.720S 2.Performante 3.GT2 RS ; great agility for the GT2 RS, thanks for 4WS and very impressive motricity thanks to its architecture. Lambo has great motricity thanks to 4WD and a great aerodynamics balance but does not like to slide/drift. 720S is the most rigid of the three and behaves like a Lotus Elise with 720PS. Easy at first sight, it is more demanding when you cut electronics assistances and get near the limit. Best brakes and accelerations.
Overall : GT2 RS is the most radical but not so difficult or scary to drive. Lambo is characterized by its wonderfull V10 and its good aerodynamics balance. It is well usable on the road. The 720S is the less radical and most polyvalent. It is nonetheless the most performante and the most effective everywhere.
 
Considering that in Sachsenring Gt 2 Rs was 2 seconds fasters with cup 2 R, i suppose it could have be much faster in this comparision with trofeo r
 
Considering that in Sachsenring Gt 2 Rs was 2 seconds fasters with cup 2 R, i suppose it could have be much faster in this comparision with trofeo r
McLaren did not have Trofeo R on Sachsenring... tyres are playing a too big role now and it's getting super tough to follow it. I suspect the much different results of the M5 may also be down to Pirelli vs Michelin debate...
But what's obvious is the Porsche/Michelin's Cup 2 R bring a tremendous advantage.
 
Thank you! These are the cars to have imo. Very impressed with the Lambo to be down at least 80 hp (perhaps up to 150 hp if the dyno numbers from the 720S are accurate) and up on weight too but <0.5 seconds off. Saw a white 720S today outside the office and I gotta say (headlights aside) the shape is fantastic; they out-Ferrari'd with their Ferrari like curves.
 

Thread statistics

Created
Laurent T,
Last reply from
lambornima,
Replies
14
Views
2,098

Back
Top